News:

SMF - Just Installed!

Main Menu

South Gare Pipit

Started by sidwemn, October 15, 2009, 05:39:26 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

sidwemn

Record shots of tonights Pipit. Must do better!!

Cheers
Martyn

sidwemn

A couple more shots

Martyn

Neil Lay

Richard's or Blyth's ?

Four more shots below. I have deliberately not (yet) tried to further sharpen the images, which may erase or introduce unwanted details.

more shots in next post. Then I will try to sharpen the best ones.

Neil

Neil Lay

Four more shots.

Cheers,
Neil

RCT

In my view, and that of those watching this bird tonight it is a Blyth's Pipit.
Features in favour of this include :
Comparatively small size, did not look huge in comparison to Meadow Pipit.
More horizontal stance on shorter legs, looked more like a 'flava' wagtail than large pipit.
Small, finer bill.
Short hindclaw, not the really long spurs of Richard's.
Heavily streaked mantle and crown.
More extensive buff wash on underparts, lacking the contrasting buff flanks.
Call, longer and slightly less harsh than Richard's, tailing off at the end, "schreooo" if that makes sense!
Finally, as can be seen from eg Martyns second shot, the newly moulted adult median coverts (the ones with buff fringes, not the whitish fringed ones) have solid dark centres with fairly squared off tips, not long, diffuse arrowhead shaped centres.
It was last seen sat motionless on the beach ca. 5 pm before flying into the dunes and was not seen again with certainty.
Could be talking absolute crap of course!
Cheers
Richard

Megsonmen

Looking at the literature to hand and the photos posted so far, I agree with Richard that it looks okay for Blyth's pipit, thouh I won't have seen it in the field until tomorrow (!). GX Megson

Neil Lay

From the stats I see that image 2538 has been viewed most times - I assume to study the wing coverts.
I have attached my best attempt to remove noise and sharpen the image. Hopefully I have not introduced or removed detail

Also I have attached another image (2529) before and after filtering which may give more wing detail.

I hope these help a bit.

Neil

Neil Lay

Two more record shots from today.

Do these images of the wing coverts and hind claw allow an identification yet?

Neil

RCT

Well done on these last 2 pics, they seem to settle the issue.
Have to admit it looks much more Richard's like now.
I, and a lot of the others who watched this bird on the first evening, cant believe how its appearance has changed since then. I still have issues with the call, size etc but cant see Blyth's in this as I could Thurs night.... ::)
Learn something new every day.........
Unless we can concoct a 2 bird theory..... ;)